Learn / Planets round other stars

The habitable zone

The physics

The equations, worked through.

  1. First look
  2. How it works
  3. The physics
  4. The frontier, still to be written

The physics

The equations, worked through

This level derives the temperature a planet would have with no air, from a balance of the energy coming in against the energy going out. It then tests the result on three real planets, where the difference from the measured temperature is the warming done by each planet’s air, and on two planets of TRAPPIST-1 whose heat the Webb telescope has measured. The sums are done here unless a source is named.

Energy in. A star of power LL spreads its light over a sphere, so at a distance dd each square metre facing it receives

S=L4πd2S = \frac{L}{4 \pi d^2}

At the Earth this is 1,361 watts on each square metre. A planet of radius RR catches the light falling on its shadow, a disc of area πR2\pi R^2. It reflects a share AA, its albedo, and absorbs the rest:

Pin=(1−A) S πR2P_{\text{in}} = (1 - A)\, S\, \pi R^2

Energy out. A warm body gives out heat as infrared light. The Stefan-Boltzmann law says each square metre at temperature TT gives out σT4\sigma T^4, where σ=5.67×10−8{\sigma = 5.67 \times 10^{-8}} W m⁻² K⁻⁴. If the planet spreads its heat round evenly, as a fast-spinning planet with air or oceans does, the whole surface, 4πR24 \pi R^2, radiates:

Pout=4πR2σT4P_{\text{out}} = 4 \pi R^2 \sigma T^4

The balance. A planet that is neither warming nor cooling gives out what it takes in. Set the two equal. The radius cancels, so a planet’s size does not matter, and

T=((1−A) S4σ)1/4T = \left(\frac{(1 - A)\, S}{4 \sigma}\right)^{1/4}

This is the equilibrium temperature. The 4 underneath comes from the ratio of the whole surface to the disc that catches the light. The fourth root means the temperature changes slowly: double the sunlight and the temperature goes up only by the fourth root of 2, about 19 per cent.

sunlight in:caught by a disc, πR²heat out:from all round, 4πR²
In through a disc, out all round. Sunlight arrives from one direction, so the planet catches only what falls on its shadow, a disc of area πR². It gives out heat from its whole surface, four times that area. That ratio is the 4 in the formula.

Real data: three planets. NASA’s fact sheets give the sunlight and albedo of each planet, and the average temperature measured at its surface.

Venus gets 2,601 watts on each square metre and reflects 0.77 of it. The Earth gets 1,361 and reflects 0.294. Mars gets 586 and reflects 0.25.

Item TT with no air Measured at the ground
Venus 227 K 737 K
The Earth 255 K 288 K
Mars 210 K about 214 K

The difference between the last two columns is the greenhouse effect. The Earth’s air warms it by 33 K, which is what keeps most of its water liquid: at 255 K, that is −18 °C, most of its water would freeze. Mars has a very thin air and is warmed by only a few degrees. Venus is the striking one. It reflects so much sunlight that with no air it would be colder than the Earth, yet its thick carbon dioxide air holds it at 737 K, hot enough to melt lead.

From temperature to a zone. The level before gave the edges of the Sun’s zone, from a 2013 model, as 0.99 and 1.70 times the Earth’s distance, where a planet gets 1.02 and 0.35 times the Earth’s sunlight. Since SS falls as 1/d21/d^2, the edges round any star are at

d=L/L⊙S/S⊕ aud = \sqrt{\frac{L / L_\odot}{S / S_\oplus}} \ \text{au}

with the star’s power in Suns and the sunlight in Earths. TRAPPIST-1 gives out 0.00055 times the Sun’s power, so its zone runs from 0.023 to 0.040 au. Its planets e, at 0.029 au, and f, at 0.038 au, are inside; d, at 0.022 au, is just closer in than the inner edge. The edges move a little for a star as cool as this, because a planet’s air reflects red light less well, which the 2013 model allows for and this simple scaling does not.

A planet with no air. The 4 in the balance assumed the heat is spread round. A planet with no air or ocean cannot do that. Each patch of ground gives out what falls on it, so the side facing the star is much hotter and the far side very cold. Averaged over the face we see when the planet is beside the star, working this through over the disc changes the 4 to 3/23/2. In terms of the star’s own surface temperature T⋆T_\star and radius R⋆R_\star, and with nothing reflected:

Tday=T⋆R⋆a(23)1/4T_{\text{day}} = T_\star \sqrt{\frac{R_\star}{a}} \left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^{1/4}

Real data: TRAPPIST-1 b and c. The archive gives the star a surface temperature of 2,566 K and a radius of 0.119 Suns. Planet b is 0.01154 au from it and c is 0.0158 au.

Detail Bare rock, from the formula Measured by Webb
TRAPPIST-1 b 508 K 503 K, give or take 27
TRAPPIST-1 c 434 K 380 K, give or take 31

If instead an air spread the heat evenly round each planet, the first formula would give 398 K for b and 340 K for c. Planet b matches bare rock almost exactly. Greene and colleagues, who measured it in 2023, worked out the same 508 K, and concluded that the planet has little or no air. Planet c falls between the two, so Zieba and colleagues could rule out a thick carbon dioxide air like Venus’s, but not a thinner one or bare rock.

Try it yourself. Use the first formula for TRAPPIST-1 e, which gets 0.646 times the Earth’s sunlight according to the archive, with the Earth’s albedo of 0.294.

The answer: about 228 K, or −45 °C. Like the Earth, it would need the warming of an air to keep water liquid. Whether it has one is what the Webb telescope is now trying to find out.

What this level leaves out. Albedo is not a fixed number: ice, cloud and the colour of the star all change it, and a planet that cools grows more ice and reflects more, which cools it further. The greenhouse warming depends on what the air is made of and how thick it is, which is what the model behind the zone’s edges works out. And a planet’s own heat from inside, which keeps the ocean of Europa liquid far outside the Sun’s zone, is left out altogether.

Where this comes from

The words are written for this site. Sums in the text are worked from the figures in these sources.